Smart #5 vs Tesla Model Y
Biggest differences: AC charging — Smart #5 22 kW, Tesla Model Y 11 kW · DC charging — Smart #5 400 kW, Tesla Model Y 250 kW · Power — Smart #5 363 PS, Tesla Model Y 514 PS.
Smart #5
Smart #5 is a D-segment SUV offering four drivetrain variants with power ranging from 340 hp to 646 hp.
Tesla Model Y
The Tesla Model Y is an electric SUV in the D segment, offering three different drive configurations with varying ranges and acceleration performance.
Profile against the market: Smart #5 vs Tesla Model Y
Smart #5Pro+
Tesla Model YPremium AWD
Smart #5 or Tesla Model Y — who wins where
Tesla Model Y leads 7 to 3
The score leaves out metrics where data is missing on one side.
Click a slice to see only those metrics. Each bar shows where the car stands against the whole catalogue.
- WLTP range kmTesla Model Y +32 km
- Battery kWhSmart #5 +15 kWh
- Consumption ↓ kWh/100 kmTesla Model Y −2.8 kWh/100 km
- Power PSTesla Model Y +151 PS
- 0–100 km/h ↓ sTesla Model Y −1.7 s
- Top speed km/hTesla Model Y +1 km/h
- DC charging kWSmart #5 +150 kW
- AC charging kWSmart #5 +11 kW
- Charging ↓ minNo data
- Weight ↓ kgTesla Model Y −263 kg
- Boot lTesla Model Y +192 l
Technical data: Smart #5 vs Tesla Model Y
Bold and underline = better value · ↓ = lower is better · — = no data
| Key parameters | Smart #5 Pro+ | Tesla Model Y Premium AWD | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Range and energy | |||
| WLTP range | 590 km | 622 km | Tesla +32 km |
| Battery | 94 kWh | 79 kWh | Smart +15 kWh |
| Consumption ↓ | 18.4 kWh/100 km | 15.6 kWh/100 km | Tesla −2.8 kWh/100 km |
| Charging | |||
| DC charging | 400 kW | 250 kW | Smart +150 kW |
| AC charging | 22 kW | 11 kW | Smart +11 kW |
| Charging 10–80% ↓ | 18 min | — | — |
| Range per minute of charging | 22.9 km/min | — | — |
| Voltage | 800 V | 400 V | Smart +400 V |
| Performance and drivetrain | |||
| Power | 363 PS | 514 PS | Tesla +151 PS |
| 0–100 km/h ↓ | 6.5 s | 4.8 s | Tesla −1.7 s |
| Top speed | 200 km/h | 201 km/h | Tesla +1 km/h |
| Drivetrain | RWD | AWD | different type |
| Practicality | |||
| Weight ↓ | 2260 kg | 1997 kg | Tesla −263 kg |
| Boot | 630 l | 822 l | Tesla +192 l |
| V2L (external power) | Yes | No | only Smart |
| Length | 4695 mm | 4790 mm | Tesla +95 mm |
| Width | 1920 mm | 1920 mm | No difference |
| Height | 1705 mm | 1624 mm | Smart +81 mm |
| Wheelbase | 2900 mm | 2890 mm | Smart +10 mm |
The better value in each row is bold and underlined in the colour of the car. Metrics marked ↓ — lower is better. Dimensions are shown without picking a winner.
Energy cost calculator
Smart #5
Tesla Model Y
Amounts are in your currency — enter prices in the currency you use.
Video reviews of both models
Tesla Model Y
Other comparisons in this class: SUV, segment D
Frequently asked questions about this comparison
Which has the longer range — Smart #5 or Tesla Model Y?
The Tesla Model Y goes further: 622 km WLTP against the 590 km of the Smart #5. That is a difference of 32 km.
Why does the Smart #5 have a bigger battery but a shorter range than the Tesla Model Y?
The Smart #5 carries 94 kWh and covers 590 km, while the Tesla Model Y with its 79 kWh battery does 622 km. Energy use decides it: 18.4 against 15.6 kWh/100 km.
How do the drivetrains of the Smart #5 and the Tesla Model Y differ?
The Smart #5 has RWD and 363 PS. The Tesla Model Y has AWD and 514 PS.
Which one can power appliances from a socket (V2L)?
Only the Smart #5 — its 94 kWh battery then works as a power source. The Tesla Model Y, with 79 kWh, does not offer it.
Technical data comes from official manufacturer materials and we do our best to verify it, but a manufacturer can change a specification without notice and mistakes do happen. Confirm the figures with a dealer before you buy — we accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this data. Full disclaimer
Range, consumption and weight are given for the base configuration: manufacturers homologate them as a band of values that depends on wheels and equipment (e.g. 533–592 km), and we take the lightest variant, on the smallest wheels — i.e. the most favourable. The same model on larger wheels will travel a shorter distance.